Napster fears closure

Napster has warned that yesterday's court ruling that it must stop its users from swapping copyrighted music files would lead to the closure of the site and has vowed to continue fighting its wider legal battles with the music industry.

Written by Linda Leung and John Geralds in Silicon Valley, vnunet.com

Napster has warned that yesterday's court ruling that it must stop its users from swapping copyrighted music files would lead to the closure of the site and has vowed to continue fighting its wider legal battles with the music industry.

Yesterday, a US court of appeal ruled that Napster would be liable for copyright infringement if it continued to allow its millions of users to trade songs that are protected by copyright. But in a message to its members, Napster said its fight against several copyright infringement lawsuits waged by the big five recording companies was not yet over.

"We still have a lot of work to do, and we need your valuable help," reads a posting on its site. It urges its users to voice their feelings and write to the record companies in support of Napster.

Advertisement

In a statement, Napster chief executive, Hank Barry, said: "The court ruled on the basis of what it recognised was an incomplete record before it. While we respect the court's decision, we believe that Napster users are not copyright infringers and we will pursue every legal avenue to keep Napster operating."

But some analysts believe the judgement is the beginning of the end for Napster. PJ McNealy, an analyst at researcher Gartner, said: "Napster got nailed, plain and simple. This decision is a major step towards shutting down the service as it currently stands."

He warned that the decision would drive swapping of illegal music deeper underground.

Meanwhile, German entertainment giant Bertelsmann, which agreed to withdraw its lawsuit once Napster implements a fee-based subscription model, said it would continue to work with the music file download company to reach a "mutually satisfactory solution".

Andreas Schmidt, president and chief executive of Bertelsmann's ecommerce group, said: "File sharing is here to stay, and we will continue working to build a membership-based Napster service that will be supported by the music industry."

But McNealy does not believe that the support of Bertelsmann is enough. He added: "Napster expects to have a new service ready this summer, but that may not be too compelling with just BMG [Bertlesmann's music label] content on it."

The judgement has also riled one US consumer electronics industry association, which accused the appeals court of "ignoring the basic principles of copyright infringement".

The Consumer Electronics Association (CEA), which represents manufacturers of audio and video systems, liken the court decision to a similar one made in 1981, which ruled that video cassette recorders (VCRs) were illegal. That decision was later overturned by the Supreme Court.

CEA president and chief executive, Gary Shapiro, said: "If that decision had stood, we would have no VCR or movie rental to the detriment of Hollywood and consumers. We can only wonder if [the Napster ruling would mean that]technology and consumer access will be limited in the future."

Tags:

Reader comments

More from Computeractive

News

The latest home computing news

Downloads

The best PC tools, applications and more

Reviews

Independent opinions on new hardware and software

Step-by-step guides

Easy-to-follow projects with pictures

PC Help

Solve PC problems with our Q&A

Videos

PC projects demonstrated and product reviews

Articles

An in-depth look at how to get the best from your PC

Magazine

What's coming up in Computeractive

Forums

Get help with your PC problems from our readers

Competitions

Your chance to win computing prizes

Shopping

Great deals on products, services and more

Computeractive CD Rom 10
All 26 issues of Computeractive from 2007 on one CD-Rom.

Ultimate Guide to PC Troubleshooting
Everything you need to know to solve your PC problems.

Create your own calendars softwareCreate your own Calendars
The fun and easy way to create your own calendars!

Computeractive - Issue 280Computeractive Back Issues
Missed an issue? Click here to find a back issue

Blogs

Windows Watch

Windows Watch

Keeping an eye on the latest XP and Vista news

Got a Mac? Get anti-virus.

02 Dec 2008Apple Mac users have long boasted that, unlike their Windows (sorry, sorry, "PC") counterparts, they don't need to spend time and money...

Download Junkie

Download Junkie

Your daily dose of download discussion

Get the free commercial version of TuneUp Utilties 2007 worth £30

01 Dec 2008Only recently did we tell you about the fantastic new release of TuneUp Utilities 2009 , which will enable you to tweak,...

Advertisement

Free email newsletters

Techno babble demystified...

[Display all definitions]

Or type in any computer-related word and click "Go"

Advertisement

Computeractive is not reponsible for content of Google adverts

Primary Navigation

© Incisive Media Ltd. 2008. Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House,
28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503

Search computeractive.co.uk