The former owner of Russian music website Allofmp3 has been acquitted of
copyright offences.
Denis Kvasov and his site had operated within the bounds of Russian law,
according to a Moscow court ruling.
Mr Kvasov, head of Mediaservices, which owned the controversial
Allofmp3
site, was put on trial after music companies
EMI,
Warner
Music Group and
Universal
music pressed for his prosecution.
They claimed that the website, which attracted around 5.5 million users a day
by offering music downloads at a fraction of the price of other download sites
like Apple's iTunes, was enabling illegal downloads by not paying royalties to
copyright holders or artists.
However, the Russian court disagreed. District judge Yekaterina Sharapova
cleared Mr Kvasov after the prosecuting music companies “did not succeed in
presenting persuasive evidence of his involvement in infringing copyright law."
During the trial, Mr Kvasov also successfully argued that he had paid
royalties to a local organisation, the Russian Multimedia and Internet Society
(Roms).
The global music trade body, the
IFPI, said
it was “very disappointed” by the decision and that it expected the “prosecutor
to appeal.”
Jo Oliver, vice president of litigation and regulatory affairs at the IFPI,
said: "MediaServices operates in clear violation of Russia’s law and we expect
this unfortunate decision will soon be reversed.
“This ruling in no way affects the illegality of allofmp3.com and similar
services that reproduce and make available music without the consent of the
artists, composers and record producers that created it.”
Although Allofmp3.com disappeared in June, another Russia-based discount
music site opened shortly afterwards.
Reader comments