Simple clear advice in plain English

Samsung not cool enough to copy iPad, High Court rules

High Court swats away Apple infringement claim

Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1

The exercise in mud-slinging currently being carried out by some of the biggest names in tech descended into farce yesterday when the High Court ruled that Samsung wasn't ‘cool' enough to copy Apple.

Apple had claimed that three of Samsung's Galaxy Tab products (Tab 10.1, Tab 8.9 and Tab 7.7) infringed its copyrights. Samsung said this wasn't the case. Apple said this was the case. Then the High Court got involved.

The ruling, by Judge Colin Birss QC, contains a delightful sound bite - Samsung's products aren't cool enough to copy the iPad.

"They do not have the same understated and extreme simplicity which is possessed by the Apple design. They are not as cool."

Purring over Apple's design, Mr Birss said it was something people ‘would want to pick up and hold'.

"It is an understated, smooth and simple product. It is a cool design", he said.

Apple is wrong and Samsung isn't cool. Justice has been done.

display:none  

Add your comment

Please keep comments constructive and free from abuse of any kind and swearing. If you wish to link to a product or service online, please do so in such a way that makes it clear that it is not spam. If you are connected to any such product you should make that clear.

We may use your comments in the magazine. We may edit your comments for clarity or to remove unacceptable material. We will attribute your comments but not share your email address.

We request your email address and record your Internet Address (IP address) in order to block spam from our site. We will never share this information without your permission.

All comments are reviewed by the Computeractive Team before being published. Please bear with the slight delay this causes, you don't need to post more than once.

Click here to read our Privacy Policy

Click here to read our site Terms & Conditions

Recent blog posts

A new home for the Caps Lock Alert program
Hosting the files for the Caps Lock Alert program on Dropbox wasn't really working. Not least because...

Gmail users: The dot in your email address is irrelevant
For the last few months I've been getting someone else's emails. Recently I received an invitation to...

Minecraft comes to the Raspberry Pi
Great news for all Raspberry Pi owners, especially those hoping to keep their children interesting in...

The broken promise of smart TVs
Smart TVs, or internet-connected TVs as they should really be called, were supposed to make watching...

Updating your subscription status Loading

Most popular articles

No matching document

Poll

Do you have Windows 8?

Jargon Buster

Computing terms explained in plain English

Bios

Basic Input-Output System. Essential software built into every PC that connects the vital components....

Great shopping deals from Computeractive

Information currently unavailable