Simple clear advice in plain English

HP agrees to repair laptop with faulty graphics card

We update a case involving a laptop computer in a range that HP said had a faulty component

john-lewis-hp
John Lewis was very helpful in solving this problem

We started investigating a complaint for Marion Bacon a while ago, long before even reporting it.

We can now tell you about the successful outcome of the case.

Mrs Bacon had bought an HP 9000 series laptop from John Lewis that she believed had a faulty graphics card.

Now although HP had issued a notice saying that for some models this was the case, not all laptops in this series had the fault.

Our task was determining if this was the case. And it took some time. It wasn't helped by the fact that Mrs Bacon lived in Spain for much of the year and only briefly visited the UK.

We managed to ascertain that her laptop was one of those that was affected by the problem. As she had bought the laptop directly from John Lewis, under the Sale of Goods Act it was this retailer's responsibility.

John Lewis was in fact very helpful. It said it would assume full responsibility if the laptop was inherently faulty. But it also offered to pay half of any repair cost even if the model was not one of those affected.

We also contacted HP because it had promised repairs for people with these faulty laptops.

After many phone calls and emails and a very helpful HP contact, Mrs Bacon has had the laptop repaired by HP.

This was the easiest way to get the problem sorted out as she was out of the country and shipping the laptop back to John Lewis in the UK was an extra headache for her.

If you have an inherently faulty product you can still get redress.

Under the Sale of Goods Act you have up to six years (five in Scotland) to seek redress.

However, you should contact your retailer in this instance. The HP alert is proof that there is an inherent problem with the product although you may find that you have to prove your problem is one and the same.

See our original story here.

Reader Comments

HP Laptop Fault

I have an HP Pavillion DV71135EA that has developed a fault which, searching the HP website, have discovered the fault is the CPU. The laptop will power up and appear to start but will not load. The LED's of 'caps lock' and between the 'pg up' and 'pg dn' flashes. This, acording to the chart on the HP website faults page is a code that identifies the fault, the number of flashes denotes the nature of the fault. I have contacted several local computer repair 'experts' and all have given me different answers to the problem but none mentioned the CPU. I contacted the Company I purchased it from, Curry's and after nearly an hour on the phone, got absolutely nowhere, I bought this laptop from one of Curry's stores that have now closed but am not concerned with this point as the main store is close to me. I purchased this laptop in February 2009 so it is not yet two years old. Although I did not take out an extended warantee I still feel that this fault, under the Sale Of Goods Act that you mention, should be rectified FOC or the laptop replaced. It is in as new condition with all oreiginal packaging and documents with original receipt of purchase. I will end by asking the question, do you think that Curry's or HP have a duty to sort it out as the HP 'alert' you report would appear to cover my laptop also?

Posted by Tim Langabeer, 25 Dec 2010

   

Add your comment

All fields must be completed. Your email address will not be displayed or used to send marketing messages.

All messages will be checked by moderators before appearing on the site.

See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Related articles

Internet forums lead to query over well-known HP laptop fault

Free-of-charge repair promise by company only applies to certain laptop models

HP launches new PCs, netbooks and laptops

3D-capable notebook included in HP's Christmas product line-up

q-a-logo

Why is my laptop touchpad behaving oddly?

If your touchpad scrolling area is causing problems, you can disable it

Question & Answer

Q.Can I open my old genealogy files or have they gone...

> Read the answer

Q.Why are odd patterns appearing on my monitors shortly...

> Read the answer

Q.How do I find out if the firewall in Windows 7 is active...

> Read the answer

Best deals on the web

img

Samsung RV520-A07

£356.50- Buy it now

img

Acer Aspire 5750G (LX.RXP02.019)

£399.99- Buy it now

img

Apple MacBook Pro (MD313B/A)

£904.37- Buy it now

Latest issue & subscription deals

Poll

Are you concerned about viruses that target mobile phones?

Jargon Buster

Computing terms explained in plain English

VoIP

Voice over IP. The routing of voice conversations over the internet, which is cheaper than the telephone...

Great shopping deals from Computeractive