Simple clear advice in plain English

Illegal file sharing powers 'too broad'

Human rights committee says Digital Economy Bill could breach internet users' rights

artist impresion of file sharing
peer2peer/filesharing-p2p

Parliament's Joint Select Committee on Human Rights (JCHR) has said some of the proposed measures to tackle illegal file sharing have the potential “to breach internet users' rights to respect for correspondence and freedom of expression”.

The Committee said today in a report that the Digital Economy Bill may have created over-broad powers. It has called on the Government to ensure this does not happen.

It also called for certain points to be clarified so MPs can assess if the penalties and powers the Bill creates are proportionate to the offence.

Andrew Dismore MP, chair of the JCHR said: "Illegal file sharing is itself a breach of important rights, but the concern we have with this Bill is that it lacks detail.

"It has been difficult, even in the narrow area we have focused on, to get a clear picture of the scope and impact of the provisions.

"The internet is constantly creating new challenges for policy makers but that cannot justify ill-defined or sweeping legislative responses, especially when there is the possibility of restricting freedom of expression or the privacy of individual users."

The Digital Economy Bill currently going through Parliament has been drawn up to update the regulation of the communications sector.

Included are measures to combat illegal file sharing. This is expected to be a step-by-step process with alleged infringers initially receiving warning letters from their internet service provider (ISP).

If this fails, technical measures such as reducing the alleged offender’s internet speeds have been proposed, and disconnection of service if these measures fail.

However, it is not clear how this information will be gathered and what appeals processes will be put in place so people can defend themselves.

The Committee also has particular concerns about the new power that allows for the Secretary of State to amend the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 by secondary legislation.

In correspondence with the Committee the Secretary of State explained that the Government intended to introduce amendments to limit the power and to use the special 'super-affirmative' procedure.

He said this would ensure that changes are better scrutinised by Parliament. This hasn’t, however, sufficiently allayed the Committee’s concerns.

It said it remained unhappy that Clause 17 remains, overly broad and that parliamentary scrutiny may remain inadequate.

Reader Comments

   

Add your comment

All fields must be completed. Your email address will not be displayed or used to send marketing messages.

All messages will be checked by moderators before appearing on the site.

See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Related articles

Parties call for Digital Economy Bill to be amended

Opposition parties want to scrap or amend Lord Mandelson's control of the Copyright law

Digital Economy Bill outlines file-sharing penalties

Government says internet accounts could be suspended if warning letters are ignored

Talk Talk slams file-sharing plans at Westminster

Pressure is mounting on the government to rethink the measures it plans to tackle illegal file sharing

Question & Answer

Q.Why can't my browser find the website address I typed...

> Read the answer

Q.All updates have been downloaded, so why won't Windows...

> Read the answer

Q.How do I stop Windows 7 search?

> Read the answer

Best deals on the web

img

Apple iMac 21.5" (MC309)

£929.00- Buy it now

img

Dell Inspiron 620 ST Intel Core i3-2100 3.10GHz / 3GB / 500GB / DVDRW / Win 7 Home Premium

£299.00- Buy it now

img

Apple iMac 27" (MC813)

£1353.99- Buy it now

Great benefits for subscribers!

Poll

Which is your preferred web browser

Jargon Buster

Computing terms explained in plain English

Virtual drive

A set of files seen by Windows as a separate hard disk.

Great shopping deals from Computeractive