Simple clear advice in plain English

Something wiki this way comes

Wikipedia is often the first point of call for anyone looking for information on the web – but is it reliable?

The site itself acknowledges that unreliable information can be posted but says that there are so many Wikipedians reading and monitoring contributions that any errors are usually corrected pretty quickly (we had to correct a minor error on the entry one of our readers created for Computeractive).

Wikipedia’s motto is: ‘Given enough eyeballs, all errors are shallow’, but be wary of specialist topics where few users would recognise mistakes. Recently added content may also be dubious – when we looked up the entry on Kate Moss we were surprised to read that she had a degree in mathematics from Cambridge University. When we looked again a few minutes later, her scholarly achievements had been erased.

Incidents like this may seem funny or trivial, but critics have warned that websites like Wikipedia can be very harmful if abused because they are so popular, particularly when entries refer to the actions of politicians, people in the public eye and companies. Wiki fans point out that Wikimedia is a work of reference and all such works are open to question.

The respected scientific journal Nature recently compared the number of inaccuracies in selected articles from Wikipedia and the Encyclopaedia Britannica. They found 162 errors in Wikipedia and 123 in Britannica. Many saw it as a hollow victory, as the study showed that no encyclopaedias – printed or online – are infallible, although the publishers of Britannica argued that Nature’s report was flawed.

So where does this leave the fact-hunting consumer? As a rule, Wikipedia is great as a starting point but don’t take information from a single source as gospel; double-check it against other sources. We think the true beauty of Wikipedia is that it can take you off at tangents that you would never have thought of because of the ease with which links in the text can be clicked.

Take a stroll through a Wikipedia article and click on some of the links. We set off from the entry on the classic satirist and wit Peter Cook and followed links to the actor Kenneth Williams, who Cook wrote for. The Carry On star’s biography led us to London King’s Cross, where Williams was born.

Wikipedia points out that this is thought to be the site of a major carry-on between the Romans and the Iceni tribe, whose queen, Boudicca, may be buried beneath platform 9 of King’s Cross station. The next link we chose took us, bizarrely, to something called Alvin and the Chipmunks. Not all Wiki strolls are that unusual, and you’ll usually find plenty of information on the subject you’re interested in.

See our Workshop about creating new entries and editing Wikipedia pages

Article tags

Reader Comments

   

Add your comment

All fields must be completed. Your email address will not be displayed or used to send marketing messages.

All messages will be checked by moderators before appearing on the site.

See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Related articles

Contribute to Wikipedia's online encyclopaedia

It's the internet encyclopaedia that anyone can edit. Here’s how to get involved

Citizens Advice Bureau

Which? boss says Government plans "vandalise" consumer rights

Plans to hand over responsibility to Citizens Advice are "shockingly ill-conceived"

Maru cat meme

Top 20 internet memes

What do deer-chasing labradors and cardboard loving cats have in common? They are memes that have taken the world by storm. We describe our favourites

Question & Answer

Q.Is my phone’s Bluetooth any use?

> Read the answer

Q.Can I switch boot drives so that I can work on older...

> Read the answer

Q.Can I open my old genealogy files or have they gone...

> Read the answer

Best deals on the web

img

Samsung RV520-A07

£356.50- Buy it now

img

Acer Aspire 5750G (LX.RXP02.019)

£399.99- Buy it now

img

Apple MacBook Pro (MD313B/A)

£904.37- Buy it now

Latest issue & subscription deals

Poll

Are you concerned about viruses that target mobile phones?

Jargon Buster

Computing terms explained in plain English

VGA

Video Graphics Array. Standard socket for connecting a monitor to a computer.

Great shopping deals from Computeractive