Simple clear advice in plain English

Bunch of fives: Worst mobile phones

Some of our worst experiences with mobile phones

image-of-iphone-app-screen

Today's mobile phones are so advanced it's easy to forget how primitive they once were. Modern handsets play music and video, take photos, have touch-sensitive screens and full internet connectivity.

But years ago, phone designers tried to replicate the look and feel of concrete bricks, while the web, if it was included, ran at a snail's pace. Worse, you might be forced to use a system called Wap, which was only good at increasing your phone bill.

We have put our heads and collective experience together to describe five of the worst experiences we've encountered when using mobile phones.

Samsung E530
Gadget manufacturers, like the teenage geeks they are at heart, are obsessed and terrified by girls in equal measure. So, they wonder: how to make a phone that will delight and enthrall the delightful creatures? And Samsung’s ham-fisted answer was the E530, a candy floss-coloured clamshell that displayed screen text in large pink letters.

But the E530’s crowning glory was its array of lady-friendly apps that included a calorie counter, a fragrance selector and the delightful pink schedule, which reminded its owner when they were due to ovulate. We doubt the team that designed this phone is currently hot on the dating scene.

Orange SPV C500
Bluetooth is useful to have on phones. When a poor reviewer has to spend four hours setting it up though, its benefits are outweighed by the misery of getting it to work. Those four hours could have been better spent doing something more exciting, such as knitting, watching the slow erosion of Mount Everest or reinstalling Windows.

Needless to say, the phone quickly made contact with a concrete wall and ended up in fifty pieces. The reviewer notes that this procedure did not resolve his Bluetooth issues.

Sony Ericsson P900
Perhaps it's unfair to include the P900 here, as it was one of the first smartphones ever released. But using it was nothing short of frustrating, especially if you removed the physical buttons and instead attempted to control it entirely with a stylus.

It supported handwriting recognition, which sounded like a good idea to engineers, but in use proved to be a pain in the proverbial. You had to learn to draw using a sequence of squiggles and lines to enter text and inevitably it would not recognise what you were trying to write, and instead fill the screen with gibberish.

Needless to say it became easier to simply allow friendships to wither and die rather than go through the torture of trying to reply to texts.

Phillips Savvy
The hideous Phillips Savvy was released in 1999, the same year The Matrix was released. Neo, the film's hero, played by Keanu Reeves, must save mankind by travelling between a virtual world and the real one. One of his tools is a special mobile phone. If Neo had carried a Phillips Savvy with him though, he would have been laughed at.

The Savvy is the ultimate example of a 90's 'brick' mobile phone, with its huge aerial, monochrome screen and tacky case made of chunky plastic. If that wasn't enough, Phillips also sold it in all sorts of revolting colours, including bright sunsick yellow.

The Savvy’s only saving grace is that if you are ever mugged while carrying one, the thieves may steal your wallet, but are certain to leave the phone.

Apple iPhone
The iPhone is supposedly the definitive smartphone. But how did it earn this title after numerous reports of the phone being unable to send or receive calls, even with full network coverage? Some iPhone owners are forced to carry a cheap handset with them just to make calls.

However, the worst thing about owning an iPhone is that it turns you into a member of a smug, pretentious herd. You are statistically likely to be a fan of inoffensive bands such as Coldplay, drive a Honda, wear sandals and socks together, and have an opinion about Lady Gaga’s choice of hat. You have definitely bored at least one person to death by detailing the functions of pointless apps to them, and resolve discussions by using your phone to look up useless facts. In short, nobody likes you.

Reader Comments

I am not smug nor a member of a pretentious herd

Your assessment of iPhone users is OTT. I bought my phone because I liked the look of it, not the number of apps that could be downloaded to it. I can't remember having bored anyone about what the iPhone can do, it isn't really a topic of conversation after all. The iPhone is, as far as I am concerned, a smart piece of modern technology which I am happy to use and possibly one of thousands who have no trouble whatsoever in sending or receiving calls. Finally your comment about not being liked because of an iPhone, please get a life, my friends couldn't care less what phone I have and I suspect that the majority of iPhone users friends feel the same.

Posted by M A Girdler, 22 Apr 2010

spot on, ish

have to agree with the story but for different reasons. unless you sit on your Butt all day in a nice clean office with your i phone proudly displayed in one of apples many pricey must have add ons, then for practical purposes then its a no brainer. slides out of pocket easily unless youve wrapped it in a bulky case which hides the bling factor,,too easily marked and scuffed. since many of us still have practical manual jobs it dosent carry very well. just like owning a Honda i guess.

Posted by colin, 24 Apr 2010

Apple i-zzzz-Phones

Now, now Computeractive Staff! Jealousy will get you nowhere! However. as an iPhone user, I do find that the number of touches required to make a phone call a bit life shortening. I mean, (she said rooting in her pocket for the thing, taking it out of its protective pounch, pressing the button to wake up screen, sliding digit across screen to unlock, touching phone icon, then the key pad icon) if I need to dial 999, I'd like to do it in double quick time!

Posted by K Alderson-Rees, 29 Apr 2010

   

Add your comment

All fields must be completed. Your email address will not be displayed or used to send marketing messages.

All messages will be checked by moderators before appearing on the site.

See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Related articles

Philips Muse 16GB

Philips Gogear Muse 3 16GB

Music and video playback with an emphasis on sound quality

Samsung tablet

Which tablet is best for you?

The Apple iPad may be leading the market but there are many other tablets out there waiting to take its place. We examine what's good and what's not so hot

Sony Ericsson Xperia Neo

Sony Ericsson Xperia Neo Android smartphone

A smart companion for fans of music and video

Question & Answer

Q.Is my phone’s Bluetooth any use?

> Read the answer

Q.Can I switch boot drives so that I can work on older...

> Read the answer

Q.Can I open my old genealogy files or have they gone...

> Read the answer

Best deals on the web

img

Apple iMac 21.5" (MC309)

£927.29- Buy it now

img

Dell Inspiron 620 ST Intel Core i3-2100 3.10GHz / 3GB / 500GB / DVDRW / Win 7 Home Premium

£329.00- Buy it now

img

ZooStorm 7877-1023

£386.38- Buy it now

Latest issue & subscription deals

Poll

Are you concerned about viruses that target mobile phones?

Jargon Buster

Computing terms explained in plain English

Restore point

A Windows backup of system files and settings.

Great shopping deals from Computeractive