Simple clear advice in plain English

We investigate: surveillance technology

The rise of monitoring technology has prompted public suspicion. We investigate whether people’s fears are justified

big-ben-cctv-uk-surveillance-image
UK surveillance is not trusted by the public

It is possible to obtain a pay-as-you-go Oyster card that can still be tracked but is not linked to your identity. Buying a train ticket also leaves electronic footprints and CCTV cameras in stations spot even those paying in cash.

On trains across the country, you can see cameras in operation when you pass the train manager’s office on a Virgin Pendolino service, observing each carriage. On buses too, small, shiny, black camera domes record what goes on.

Once in a shopping centre, CCTV cameras operated by individual stores and by the centre itself, in conjunction with the police, keep an eye out for shoplifters. But private companies that are not connected directly with the centre may also be monitoring your movements while you shop, sometimes in novel ways.

One such system is Footpath, run by Path Intelligence of Portsmouth in Hampshire. The system works by detecting the signals of mobile phones and is already installed in several shopping centres in the south of England, including the Gunwharf Quays centre in Portsmouth.

However, even this system, which sounds slightly sinister at first, is strictly controlled and anonymous, as Path Intelligence is at pains to explain. “When we developed Footpath we contacted a number of organisations including Liberty, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and the Information Commissioner’s Office.

"Acting on their feedback we introduced important changes to our system to make it more secure. We are continually looking to engage with critics and improve our practices,” a company spokesman said.

But isn’t it possible that the collected data could identify individuals? “We have no idea who you are as an individual,” said Path Intelligence. “We only look at the path your phone takes­ – it’s like looking at a dot moving around. In isolation this information isn’t too interesting until you look at the wider trends and see many dots taking the same route or visiting the same areas.”

By noting when and where these dots collect, security staff can be directed to places where pickpockets are most likely to strike, for instance. By discovering which areas of a shopping centre are more popular, cleaning staff can be better deployed, too.

One criticism of this type of system is that, if hacked, individuals could be identified without their knowledge or consent. As a result all phone IDs are automatically scrambled before use.

Article tags

Reader Comments

The ICO, Gawd help us

Is this the same ICO that refused to enforce the Privacy in Electronic Communications (reg 7 and 8) against BT? The same ICO that said Detica and VirginMedia's interception of customers p2p was OK. Even after the ISPA admitted it wasn't? http://www.ispa.org.uk/press_office/page_62.html The same ICO that has no powers to back up any penalties it hands out ? http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest_contributors/article6702869.ece The same ICO who admitted they had no trained IT or computer personnel on their staff? The ICO are as much use as a chocolate fireguard and a complete waste of taxpayers money.

Posted by PingusPeritatus, 08 Feb 2010

police state

we are rapidly heading in the direction of cold war Russia i.e. a total police state where the individual freedom of choice was non existent. this is all being done in a very insidious way,using numerous excuses. in the name of terrorism is the one that readily springs to mind. i9 myself have been subjected to this inceasing culture which meant my fingerprints and DNA are now being kept on police records and which i cannot get removed even though i have not been convicted of any crime. i am sure this comment will be ready by some dubious body in government circles

Posted by ian duff, 12 Feb 2010

This is just the beginning

Authorities will not be happy until we all have a chip planted in our skulls which identifies us where ever we are, but more than that it will be used as a payment means instead of credit cards. Without this chip you will not be able to live in the society. As humans we would never agree to anything like this. Being human however we have feelings, one of which is fear. Our fear is being fed terrorist stories till eventually we as humans will opt for this chip. Then one person will have total control. Pretty scary stuff!

Posted by Trackable Footprint, 12 Feb 2010

Revenue Source

As the introduction of more hybrid, fully electronic vehicles come into use then the government has to find a new revenue source. The tagging of vehicle movements provides this and we will be charged through miles logged either by our number plates or tracking of electronic VIN's. You can bet that as fast the the government find ways of introducing electronic tagging of vehicles then the criminal fraternity will have found ways of counteracting them and passing them on to other users, just as they have already found ways around the chip and pin system.

Posted by Peter, 13 Feb 2010

Caged animals

The current trends of surveilance are creating a societal cage from which we cannot escape,we are nothing more than cattle,who work,spend ,eat,spend,sleep,spend.All the official and government bodies are interested in is staying at the top of the dunghill.

Posted by john, 05 Feb 2011

1984....

I suggest that if anybody should be in any doubt as to how far we've allowed ourselves to go down the Surveillance State" route, I suggest they read or re-read George Orwell's 1984. I hadn't read it for years, but you can clearly see that we're getting there at a much greater speed than most people realise.

Posted by Steve Ling, 25 Apr 2011

   

Add your comment

All fields must be completed. Your email address will not be displayed or used to send marketing messages.

All messages will be checked by moderators before appearing on the site.

See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Related articles

spam-spam-spam

ICO closing in on people behind annoying spam text messages

Privacy watchdog is launching raids on those suspected of being behind claim and debt management texts

orange-phone

ICO urges people to record phone numbers that send spam texts

Complaints about spam text messages to privacy watchdog rocket over the last few months, with the ICO receiving 1,008 from victims this year already

Surveillance Britain

The rise of surveillance and databases in the UK has led to comparisons with Big Brother. Are our fears justified?

Question & Answer

Q.Is my phone’s Bluetooth any use?

> Read the answer

Q.Can I switch boot drives so that I can work on older...

> Read the answer

Q.Can I open my old genealogy files or have they gone...

> Read the answer

Best deals on the web

img

Apple iMac 21.5" (MC309)

£927.29- Buy it now

img

Dell Inspiron 620 ST Intel Core i3-2100 3.10GHz / 3GB / 500GB / DVDRW / Win 7 Home Premium

£329.00- Buy it now

img

ZooStorm 7877-1023

£386.38- Buy it now

Latest issue & subscription deals

Poll

Are you concerned about viruses that target mobile phones?

Jargon Buster

Computing terms explained in plain English

Restore point

A Windows backup of system files and settings.

Great shopping deals from Computeractive