Computer manufacturer Fujitsu-Siemens has announced a new labelling system to
show buyers which of its products are the most environmentally friendly.
The 'Green IT' label will be used to rate products including the company's
Amilo and Lifebook desktop and laptop computers.
Some computers will not qualify for the green label, but those that do will
be marked with a Green IT badge showing either one, two or three stars. The
rating takes into account the energy consumed during the entire life of each
product, from its manufacture to eventual recycling.
For example, a three star-rated product must use halogen-free material, have
manuals printed on chlorine-free paper, and it must be possible for one person
to disassemble the computer for recycling using commonly available tools. All
plastic parts weighing over 25g must be labelled for recycling.
A three-star product must also be energy-efficient during use. Three-star PCs
must operate at 80 per cent power efficiency and notebooks at 85 per cent,
whether they are running at 20, 50 or 80 per cent of their possible speed.
The company claims that in some respects its scheme is one of the strictest
environmental ratings schemes in existence. For example, the Nordic Swan
qualification makes an exception for hazardous materials used on printed circuit
boards, while Fujitsu's scheme does not.
Fujitsu-Siemens says it chose to create its own rating system after finding
that none of the currently available schemes was suitable, with some setting
impossibly high targets and others using certifications that are so limited as
to be worthless.
“It is possible to develop a three-star system today, but it is not trivial
to have one star on every system,” said Fujitsu-Siemens vice president Dr Berndt
Kosch. “If you look at some other systems, some are so trivial that every
product is labelled.”
Of the 30 systems already tested, only six have been awarded the top three
-star rating. “If products don't carry the label, this is also an indication,”
said Dr Kosch.
The company says it will publish the specification for the labels, and is
inviting other companies to use the scheme, but Dr Kosch told Computeractive
that he did not expect the company's competitors to join. He also acknowledged
the dangers of an individual approach.
“The bad thing would be if everybody comes up with their own label,” he said.
“I hope they are compatible.”
In a statement, Fujitsu-Siemens' chief technology officer, Joseph Reger, said
that the company “would not hesitate in adopting a suitable industry-standard
labelling system, should one be introduced in the future”.
Greenpeace said the scheme could be helpful "In as much as it helps a
potential Fujitsu-Siemens customer to differentiate between the different levels
of 'green goodness' of their products", but said the company should go further.
"I don't think Fujitsu-Siemens creating more labels is especially helpful",
said a spokesperson. "Why doesn't it make all its products 3-star - then it
wouldn't need to rate the more regressive models?"
Reader comments