Finnish mobile phone giant
Nokia has
filed a lawsuit against
Apple
alleging that the iPhone infringes 10 of its patents.
Nokia filed a 30-page complaint in the Delaware District Court on 22 October.
It lists 10 US patents that, it says, are "essential" to the GSM, UMTS and IEEE
802.11 wireless standards.
The complaint claims that "Nokia has made various offers to Apple for F/RAND
(Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory) terms and conditions of a license
agreement... either individually or together with other Nokia essential patents.
"
"Apple has rejected Nokia's offers... and thereby refused to compensate
Nokia on F/RAND terms," it added. "Nokia has no choice but to file this
Complaint in order to enforce its right to be compensated."
The patents in question include five detailing techniques for wireless
transmission of data, two for speech coding and three for security and
encryption techniques. The earliest, which Nokia claims is essential to the
GSM,
UMTS
and
802.11
standards, dates from 1998.
Nokia claims that it has agreements with "approximately 40 companies,
including virtually all the leading mobile device vendors", licensing those
firms to use the technologies in question.
"The basic principle in the mobile industry is that those companies that
contribute in technology development to establish standards
create
intellectual property, which others then need to compensate for," said Nokia
vice-president Ilkka Rahnasto. "Apple is also expected to follow this principle.
"
A spokesperson for Apple said the company "doesn't comment on pending
litigation".
News of the lawsuit follows financial results that throw the companies'
current fortunes into stark contrast. On 15 October Nokia declared a quarterly
loss of 559m Euro, while on 19 October Apple posted quarterly profits of
$1.67bn.
Reader comments