image of the Talk Talk logo
Talk Talk fires warning shot over proposed three strikes rule

Talk Talk slams Government's file-sharing plans

ISP threatens legal action and says plans 'substitute proper judicial process for a kangaroo court'

Written by Dinah Greek, Computeractive

Talk Talk has warned the Government it will not disconnect users accused of illegal file sharing unless it receives concrete proof of guilt.

The internet service provider (ISP) owned by Carphone Warehouse said the proposals outlined by Lord Mandelson ignored the accepted 'innocent until proven guilty' presumption under British law.

Andrew Heaney, Talk Talk’s executive director of strategy and regulation told Computeractive the ISP was not afraid to stand up for its customers.

Advertisement

“We will not cut off our customers’ internet connection and will take it [the Government] to court if necessary. The process outlined by Lord Mandelson substitutes proper judicial process for a kangaroo court. It is wrong and we also believe it is a breach of human rights, ” he said.

The prospect of internet disconnection for persistent offenders, often called the three strikes rule, is expected to be set out this month in the Digital Economy Bill.

The rights holders will only have access to an IP address, so they must apply to the courts for an ISP to hand over customer details.

The ISP is required to send alleged illegal fire-sharers an initial warning letter. This is the first time the customer will be aware that they have been accused of illegal file sharing. If the ignore the initial letter, the ISP will be required to send futher letters.

Mr Heaney said although people have the right to appeal, He said it is wrong to presume the customer is guilty from the start.

“This is not the way British justice is meant to work,” he said.

He also pointed out that the process is riddled with unresolved issues such as how long a person’s internet service would have to be disconnected.

TalkTalk has started a Don’t Disconnect us campaign and people can sign a petition on the Number 10 website. People can also visit the site to keep up to date with the latest developments on the disconnection proposals.

Reader comments

More from Computeractive

News

The latest home computing news

Downloads

The best PC tools, applications and more

Reviews

Independent opinions on new hardware and software

Step-by-step guides

Easy-to-follow projects with pictures

PC Help

Solve PC problems with our Q&A

Videos

PC projects demonstrated and product reviews

Articles

An in-depth look at how to get the best from your PC

Magazine

What's coming up in Computeractive

Forums

Get help with your PC problems from our readers

Competitions

Your chance to win computing prizes

Shopping

Great deals on products, services and more

Computeractive Back Issue CD-Rom 11
All 26 issues of Computeractive from 2008 on one CD-Rom.

Ultimate Guide to Free Computing
Find out how you can get free software, services and more!

Create your own calendars softwareCreate your own Calendars
The fun and easy way to create your own calendars!

Computeractive - Issue 280Computeractive Back Issues
Missed an issue? Click here to find a back issue

Blogs

Windows Watch

Windows Watch

Keeping an eye on the latest XP and Vista news

Office 2010 preview

I had a meeting with Microsoft to have a look at Office 2010 and some of the changes that are being made....

Download Junkie

Download Junkie

Your daily dose of download discussion

Create and manage your own site with TOWeb

Most businesses now have their own websites, even if it's only a few pages describing what it is they do....

Advertisement

Free email newsletters

Techno babble demystified...

[Display all definitions]

Or type in any computer-related word and click "Go"

Advertisement

Computeractive is not reponsible for content of Google adverts

Primary Navigation

© Incisive Media Investments Limited 2010, Published by Incisive Financial Publishing Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, are companies registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 04252091 & 04252093

Search computeractive.co.uk
opfine.com - markets sentiment analysis