Confusion continues over cookie consent

Wording of EU rules could lead advertisers into inadvertently breaking the law

Written by Dinah Greek, Computeractive

New rules that have been designed to protect people from intrusive cookies could have the opposite effect and give internet users a huge headache.

Under the European Union's Telecoms Package of reforms, people will have to personally approve every cookie that attempts to download to their PC. An exception exists where the cookie is "strictly necessary" for the provision of a service "explicitly requested" by the user.

The change to the law raises the possibility that people visiting websites for the first time will be plagued with pop-up windows, and will have to spend time manually approving every cookie that the site tries to download.

Advertisement

One web page alone can contain multiple cookies, as can adverts on those web pages.

Advertising trade bodies, such as the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) Europe have claimed that a person’s browser settings will imply prior consent.

A 'recital', or non-binding preamble, to the text in the reforms does say that some cookies can be consented to this way.

However Struan Robertson, technology lawyer at Pinsent Masons law firm is not so sure.

"I don't think browser settings achieve strict compliance with the rules. Most accept cookies by default and the user has to actively change the settings to block cookies, and I suspect that most people do not.

“Both the recital and rules refer to the need to give "clear and comprehensive information" before cookies are stored. Browsers can't give you that information because they can't tell you how a site will use the cookies it serves - so you need to get that information from the website privacy policy.

“The Directive is worded such that you should get this information before the cookie is served - not afterwards,” he said.

Cookies are small text files placed on a PC when a person visits a website. They have various aims such as ensuring relevant content is shown when a person re-visits a site, or to help with online sales and services

When rejecting cookies, this can have an adverse affect on some sites; for example some shopping carts or login systems won’t work without them.

Reader comments

More from Computeractive

News

The latest home computing news

Downloads

The best PC tools, applications and more

Reviews

Independent opinions on new hardware and software

Step-by-step guides

Easy-to-follow projects with pictures

PC Help

Solve PC problems with our Q&A

Videos

PC projects demonstrated and product reviews

Articles

An in-depth look at how to get the best from your PC

Magazine

What's coming up in Computeractive

Forums

Get help with your PC problems from our readers

Competitions

Your chance to win computing prizes

Shopping

Great deals on products, services and more

Computeractive Back Issue CD-Rom 12
All 26 issues of Computeractive from 2009 on one CD-Rom.

Ultimate Guide to Free Computing
Find out how you can get free software, services and more!

Learn to use Windows 7
Learn to use Windows 7
Everything you need to know about using Windows 7!

Computeractive - Issue 280Computeractive Back Issues
Missed an issue? Click here to find a back issue

Blogs

Windows Watch

Windows Watch

Keeping an eye on the latest XP and Vista news

Norton Smartphone Security for Android: First Photos

Exclusive first photos of Symantec's Smartphone Security for Android, taken at Symantec's headquarters. Story here .

Download Junkie

Download Junkie

Your daily dose of download discussion

It's live! Get AVG Anti-Virus 9, worth £26.99, FREE for one day only!

Probably our biggest giveaway for a while, we're offering you the full current AVG Anti-Virus 9 [1-PC, 1-Year], worth £26.99, completely FREE...

Advertisement

Free email newsletters

Techno babble demystified...

[Display all definitions]

Or type in any computer-related word and click "Go"

Advertisement

Computeractive is not reponsible for content of Google adverts

Primary Navigation

© Incisive Media Investments Limited 2010, Published by Incisive Financial Publishing Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, are companies registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 04252091 & 04252093

Search computeractive.co.uk
opfine.com - markets sentiment analysis