Simple clear advice in plain English

Editing HD footage

How to get around the editing problems posed by high-definition video

If you thought playing HD video on your PC could be demanding, wait until you try to edit it. As an increasing number of consumer cameras capture HD content, more of us are discovering this footage is a serious stumbling block for even the latest hardware configurations.

The biggest problems lie with the latest generations of camcorders and still cameras, which compress their footage into a variant of the Mpeg4 compressor such as H.264 or AVCHD. These formats are efficient at storing and transporting HD material, but they were never designed for editing.

AVCHD and H.264 are complex formats that require significant processing muscle just for smooth, linear playback, so it’s not surprising that editing them in a non-linear application is going to cause problems. If you try to edit these formats on most PCs, you’ll suffer from an infuriatingly choppy experience where precise editing points are almost impossible to set and smooth real-time previews are out of the question.

As discussed in the March 2009 Inside Information column, the traditional solution of throwing greater processing muscle at the problem just won’t work either ­ – yet. Today’s fastest processors, even coupled with stacks of Ram and quick Raid arrays, are still insufficient for delivering the kind of responsive editing experience with AVCHD and H.264 that we’ve become used to with Mini DV.

However, this doesn’t mean anyone who received an HD camera at Christmas has to wait for hardware to catch up before they can edit footage without tearing their hair out. The answer is to take inspiration from the pros and forget about trying to edit HD in a native acquisition format such as AVCHD. Instead convert it into something that’s more editing-friendly.

Intermediates
Professional video editors have long relied on intermediary formats, which accelerate the editing process and the speed of final export times. A separate program will convert existing files or perform the conversion during the captu ring process. The intermediary files are then dropped into the timeline of your editing application as normal. Some editing applications can even create the intermediary files for you.
The milder compression used by intermediary files means they will occupy more space on your hard disk, but the files are often dispensed with after the editing process anyway.

Reader Comments

Phew !

I purchased a Samsung vp-mx20 camcorder which records it's video in h264 format. I took it on holday to record my events. I'm really pleased with it's performance and comparing the video to my existing canon dv camcorder, I find it's acceptable.....BUT Editing the video was a nightmare. I didn't realise that h264 would be a problem. After using 4 editing programs pinnacle studio 12 was the only one which coped, but only just. Eventually I had to convert every scene into mpeg2 and edit these. Sometimes I had to convert the same scene twice because the audio was missing. I looked for video converting programs but those I tried would not recognise that the video was shot 16:9. Even with studio12 I had to tell studio that a scene was 16:9. There is not a method to tell it that all scenes are 16:9. In all I had to process 532 scenes individually. Phew.. I will have to wait I suppose until software catches up. What a shame. I don't understand why a cheap none HD camcorder selected h264 instead of mpeg2. SD memory cards are cheap enough and there's really no need for high compression.

Posted by peter chapman, 16 Jul 2009

all format, no problem

Its true, converting HD format, is a weast of work and time. But the best, price&Qaulity editing program is grass valley NEO2 or Edius5. For beginners in NEO 2 the best price and tool to make real pro video productions. For more advance vid editors, there is Edius 5.Test it for free.

Posted by peters video productions, 12 Dec 2009

   

Add your comment

All fields must be completed. Your email address will not be displayed or used to send marketing messages.

All messages will be checked by moderators before appearing on the site.

See our Privacy Policy for more information.

Related articles

Everything 3D illustration

Discover everything about 3D

We explain all you need to know about the latest advances in 3D technology

roxio

Corel launches its first Roxio product

Software converts VHS into digital format

Apple Final Cut Pro X

Apple Final Cut Pro X video-editing software

Apple’s newest video-editor concentrates on home users

Question & Answer

Q.Why are some of the keys on my keyboard doing strange...

> Read the answer

Q.Is my phone’s Bluetooth any use?

> Read the answer

Q.Can I switch boot drives so that I can work on older...

> Read the answer

Best deals on the web

img

Apple iMac 21.5" (MC309)

£926.40- Buy it now

img

Dell Inspiron 620 ST Intel Core i3-2100 3.10GHz / 3GB / 500GB / DVDRW / Win 7 Home Premium

£329.00- Buy it now

img

ZooStorm 7877-1023

£386.38- Buy it now

Latest issue & subscription deals

Poll

Are you concerned about viruses that target mobile phones?

Jargon Buster

Computing terms explained in plain English

Bittorrent

A technology for downloading files. Allows even very large files to be downloaded quickly.

Great shopping deals from Computeractive